The common consensus is that percolators brew stronger coffee because you're basically getting double brewed coffee on the first go. On the other hand, a drip coffee maker only runs water through once, making a brew that is cleaner and less strong. ... With a percolator, you are going to get a strong, bold coffee.

Is percolator coffee any good?

The truth is, percolators are generally not well-beloved in the specialty coffee community. They're typically considered to be a lower level of coffee brewing because they don't produce coffee with as much balance or clarity as, say, a pour over cone.

What are the drawbacks of a coffee percolator?

Percolators Are Prone to Make a Mess

Since the coffee made in a percolator rises and pools in the upper part, if it is not taken off the heat in time then it will most likely spill over and leak all over the stovetop. Cleaning coffee stains off anything is not easy, but it can be mitigated.