Trigonometric Equation

Trigonometric Equation
$\begingroup$

I have been trying to solve this equation for over a week now: $$\tan5x-2\tan3x=\tan3x\tan5x$$

I found one solution $x=k\pi$ but I cannot prove that this is the only solution. It is equivalent to: $$\sin 5x \cos 3x - 2 \sin 3x \cos 5x = \sin 3x \sin 5x$$ $$\sin 2x =\sqrt 2 \sin 3x \sin(5x+ \frac{\pi}{4})$$ $$2\sin x \cos x =2\sqrt 2 \sin x \cos (2x +1) \sin(5x+ \frac{\pi}{4})$$ So one solution is $x=k\pi$. But how to proceed with the remaining: $$\sqrt 2 \cos x = 2\cos (2x +1) \sin(5x+ \frac{\pi}{4}) $$ It seems impossible to use derivatives to prove that it has no solution because the argument of the third cosine is shifted by $\frac{\pi}{4}$

$\endgroup$
5

2 Answers

$\begingroup$

Multiply $$ \tan(5x)-2\tan(3x)=\tan(3x)\tan(5x) $$ by $\cos(3x)\cos(5x)$ and cancel to get $$ \begin{align} 0 &=\sin(5x)\cos(3x)-2\sin(3x)\cos(5x)-\sin(3x)\sin(5x)\\ &=\tfrac12(\sin(8x)+\sin(2x))-2\cdot\tfrac12(\sin(8x)-\sin(2x))-\tfrac12(\cos(2z)-\cos(8x))\\ &=\tfrac12(\cos(8x)-\sin(8x)+3\sin(2x)-\cos(2x))\\ &=\tfrac12(\sqrt2\sin(8x+\tfrac34\pi)+\sqrt{10}\sin(2x-\arctan(\tfrac13)))\\ \end{align} $$ There doesn't appear to be any simple way to solve this other than numerically.

The function has a period of $\pi$. Plotting, it appears that this function has $4$ roots in $[0,\pi)$.

$\hspace{8mm}$

Numerically, the roots in $[0,\pi)$ are $$ x=\left\{\begin{array}{} 0.0000000000000000000\\ 0.3598476319540602998\\ 1.6915164344292107407\\ 3.0829964597422711815 \end{array}\right. $$

$\endgroup$
$\begingroup$

Making my comment into an answer, as requested:

Wolfram Alpha thinks there are more solutions (none of which ---apart from the multiples of $\pi$--- are very attractive). See here.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

James H. Sterling
Author

James H. Sterling

James Sterling reports on renewable energy developments, climate policy, ecological conservation, and green tech innovations around the globe.