Why are my eyes squishy?

Don’t worry; the cause is harmless! The squeaking noise is escaping air that was trapped in the lacrimal system—the structure housing the tear ducts. When you rub your eyes, you manipulate and put pressure on the tear duct, which causes a “squishing sound of air and tears.”

Are eyes jelly-like?

The center of the eye is filled with a jelly-like substance called “vitreous.” At a young age, this substance is very thick with a consistency somewhat like “Jell-o”. As a natural process of aging, the vitreous becomes more liquefied as one gets older.