A gun was found in the resident bad boy's car that seemingly linked him to the crime, and in flashbacks, Jack seemed to remember him at his bar the night he was shot. However, many Virgin River fans aren't convinced Brady pulled the trigger. There are many hints that suggest Brady didn't actually shoot Jack.

Did Brady really shoot Jack?

We thought we might get some answers in season 3, which hit Netflix earlier this month, but no such luck. Jack (Martin Henderson) still can't remember who shot him, and Brady (Benjamin Hollingsworth) has been arrested as the culprit in what's most likely a frame job.

Who really shot Jack in Virgin River?

Virgin River season 4: Mike hired Todd to murder Jack Sheridan in surprise betrayal theory.