Vintage Care Bears are now prized items for serious toy collectors, and they can fetch hundreds – or even possibly thousands – of dollars. ... On rare occasions, some special Care Bears or Care Bear collections could go for upwards of a whopping $10,000.

Which Care Bear is worth the most?

One of the most valuable Care Bear is the super rare Nobleheart Horse Care Bears Cousin - a highly-coveted vintage piece which can fetch around the $800 mark. Also in demand is the Proudheart Cat Care Bear Cousin, which is worth more than $500.

What is the rarest Carebear?

Noble Heart Horse Care Bear: These Care Bear toys belong to the Care Bear Cousin line and are shaped like a unicorn. They are the rarest care bear.