Penny passed away in 1999, and Anthony passed away in 2012. Authorities have some theories about the case. While Anthonette did have an Uncle Joe at the time, police interviewed him and deemed he was not a suspect. Today, authorities believe Anthonette is deceased, but they have never located her body.

Is anthonette Cayedito alive?

Anthonette Christine Cayedito /əntoʊnɛt kaɪeɪdɪtoʊ/ (born December 25, 1976) is a Native American girl who disappeared from her home in Gallup, New Mexico, on April 6, 1986. Although law enforcement officials believe her to be deceased, she is still officially listed as a missing person and her case remains open.

How old is Anthonette Cayedito now?

Anthonette Cayedito was nine-years-old when she disappeared. Today, she would be in her 30's.