A few rocks can produce an extreme reaction with hydrochloric acid. These are usually rocks composed of calcite or aragonite with abundant pore space or extremely high surface areas. ... If more is used an even more vigorous reaction will occur. (These extreme reactions will not occur with every specimen of these rocks.

What mineral does HCl react with?

Dilute hydrochloric acid will react with carbonates such as calcite to give off appreciable bubbles of carbon dioxide in a relatively short period of time. Minerals such as dolomite have to be powdered (increasing surface area) to give an observable reaction.

Does halite react with HCl?

TASTE - Certain minerals like halite (salty) and sulfur (bitter) have characteristic "flavors." ... REACTION TO ACID - The mineral reacts by "fizzing" with dilute HCl reacts with carbonate minerals.