'The Magicians': Actor Arjun Gupta bids adieu to Penny-40 while fans cheer his return: 'My heart is whole again' The Penny Adiyodi (Arjun Gupta) of Timeline-40 died in Season 3 but was soon replaced by the Penny from Timeline-23. ... Though Penny-23 has been around for two seasons now, fans still prefer the original.

What happened to the original penny?

Penny had been suffering from “super cancer” for months, but Julia (Stella Maeve) and Kady (Jade Tailor) managed to summon a demon that feeds on cancer to cure him. Unfortunately, it proved too little too late, and Penny died while the demon was feeding.

What happens to Penny on the magicians?

6 Penny. Penny had to deal with a lot of things this season including acting as Dean of Brakebills in Fogg's absence, losing the ability to travel safely, breaking up with Julia after expressing a desire to settle down and live a normal life.