Toby was supposed to die in Season 1, as in the books he committed suicide. Toby was forced to have sex with Jenna in the show. In the book he only had a crush on Emily, in the show they are best friends. Toby's death has been faked twice in the show.

Does Toby die in PLL Season 3?

Spencer is heartbroken and, throughout the season, this becomes increasingly obvious. Later, Spencer reveals to the Liars that Toby is a member of the "A-Team", and she has known about it for weeks. ... However, in A DAngerous GAme, it was revealed that Toby is alive and that the body Spencer found was a John Doe.

What happened to Toby in PLL Season 6 Episode 7?

Not only is Toby a major buzz kill about everything, he accidentally eats a bunch of Spencer's pot-laced candy (side note: AHAHAHAHA) and ends up getting completely wasted. Like, to the point where he shows up at Jason and Charles' meeting spot and is seeing double.