How To Tell If Cantaloupe Is Bad? Discard cantaloupes that: Feel light, hollow, or super soft. If the melon seems empty inside or the rind is soft, it's lost most of its water and it's no good.

Should cantaloupe be soft or crunchy?

Feel it: A good cantaloupe should feel firm all over—but not rock hard. If you find any soft or squishy spots, that's usually a sign of rotting. Gently press the blossom end: you should feel a bit of give.

Why is my cantaloupe soft?

Overripe Cantaloupe Texture

Just like watermelons, cantaloupes start turning mushy and a little grainy when overripe. They're very tender when perfectly ripe, turning seriously soft as they continue to mature. Unlike watermelons, which get dried out over time, cantaloupes get juicier as they age.