They famously blessed Cecil with the physical trait of a third eye on his forehead, even though that particular factoid has never been mentioned or confirmed in the actual show. "I don't have a third eye," Baldwin says with a laugh.

Does Cecil Palmer have three eyes?

There is no canon basis for Cecil having a third eye. It was a popular concept early on in the drawing of him by fanartists, but it's one that seems to have been slowly falling out of fashion lately. Many fanartists have abandoned the literal eye in favour of either a tattoo eye, or nothing.

Why is Cecil afraid of mirrors?

In "Ghost Stories", it was implied that, due to his crippling fear of mirrors most likely due subconsciously to the events in "Cassette", Cecil doesn't actually know what he looks like.