It can be tempting to put the extra bagels in the fridge – stop! These will cause them to dry out quickly. Instead, we recommend storing the bagels in a plastic bag at room temperature. Be sure to squeeze as much air out of the bag as possible.

What is the best way to store fresh bagels?

Contrary to popular belief, refrigerating your bagels will actually make them go stale more quickly. You should store them in plastic bags at room temperature, or freeze them immediately. Make sure your bagels aren't still warm when you put them in bags or they will get soggy.

Do bagels have to be refrigerated?

No. Bagels, like all bread, do not need to be refrigerated. Putting your bagels in the fridge will cause them to go stale faster than if you leave them at room temperature. ... happens about six times faster at refrigerator temperatures than at room temperature."